Cake Eye Liner
Rating: 
- Mommy, she's crying BLACK tears!
The BEN NYE CAKE EYELINER requires a study hand to put on and lot's of experience mixing the right amount of water with the cake to control the opacity of the color.
So if you're not experienced in doing this, it can be a lessen in frustration. Also, if you don't follow up with some sort of sealer the eyeliner will run and smear! In fact, you can remove it with just a wet napkin.
Remember the "Brady Bunch" epsiode where a woman started crying and her mascara ran and Cindy said, "Mommy! She's crying black tears!" Well that's what will happen to you if you don't follow the application of this eyeliner with a sealer.
I don't know why some of the other reviewers failed to mention that. Water is what activates the cake eyeliner in the first place, so how can the eyeliner remain water-proof and fixed without the addition of a separate product?
IMO, you have more control with a pencil and it stays on longer. Maybelline's eyeliner/brow pencil is still the best.
Rating: 
- Would repurchase again..but no need for awhile...
This is going to last me awhile since there is enough product for many applications. I am still trying to come up with a good product at home to mix it with other than water.
Rating: - Cake Eyeliner--The Best
I love this product.Being blond, without eyeliner and mascara I have what I call that "reptilian look".Having exhausted my brick & mortar search for matte cake eyeliner, Amazon saved the day.With a good (thin) brush, you can mix this to just the right consistancy and paint away!My only wish is that Ben Nye would add to the color selection and make it in navy, medium to dark green, and white.
Rating: - Cannot live without this Ben Nye Cake Liner! It's fabulous!
This is now my all time favorite, absolute MUST HAVE black eye liner! Wow! I love it!! I used to use MAC Fluidline, and Ben Nye is SO much easier to work with & black as sin!!!
I recommend this to everyone!
I use Medusa's Make Up Eye Liner Seal with the Ben Nye Cake Liner - utter perfection. Stays put over 14 hours, without a smudge or crease or any other imperfection!
Try it, i think it may just be your new favorite product!
Rating: - hard to find
This cake eyeliner is the best.Cake eyeliner is so hard to find, let alone at a reasonable price.It goes on well and lasts all day.Definately would recommend it if you are looking for a good cake eyeliner
- Mommy, she's crying BLACK tears!The BEN NYE CAKE EYELINER requires a study hand to put on and lot's of experience mixing the right amount of water with the cake to control the opacity of the color.
So if you're not experienced in doing this, it can be a lessen in frustration. Also, if you don't follow up with some sort of sealer the eyeliner will run and smear! In fact, you can remove it with just a wet napkin.
Remember the "Brady Bunch" epsiode where a woman started crying and her mascara ran and Cindy said, "Mommy! She's crying black tears!" Well that's what will happen to you if you don't follow the application of this eyeliner with a sealer.
I don't know why some of the other reviewers failed to mention that. Water is what activates the cake eyeliner in the first place, so how can the eyeliner remain water-proof and fixed without the addition of a separate product?
IMO, you have more control with a pencil and it stays on longer. Maybelline's eyeliner/brow pencil is still the best.
- Would repurchase again..but no need for awhile...This is going to last me awhile since there is enough product for many applications. I am still trying to come up with a good product at home to mix it with other than water.
- Cake Eyeliner--The BestI love this product.Being blond, without eyeliner and mascara I have what I call that "reptilian look".Having exhausted my brick & mortar search for matte cake eyeliner, Amazon saved the day.With a good (thin) brush, you can mix this to just the right consistancy and paint away!My only wish is that Ben Nye would add to the color selection and make it in navy, medium to dark green, and white.
- Cannot live without this Ben Nye Cake Liner! It's fabulous!This is now my all time favorite, absolute MUST HAVE black eye liner! Wow! I love it!! I used to use MAC Fluidline, and Ben Nye is SO much easier to work with & black as sin!!!
I recommend this to everyone!
I use Medusa's Make Up Eye Liner Seal with the Ben Nye Cake Liner - utter perfection. Stays put over 14 hours, without a smudge or crease or any other imperfection!
Try it, i think it may just be your new favorite product!
- hard to findThis cake eyeliner is the best.Cake eyeliner is so hard to find, let alone at a reasonable price.It goes on well and lasts all day.Definately would recommend it if you are looking for a good cake eyeliner