Cake Eye Liner
Rating: 
- best eyeliner
This is the best eyeliner I have ever used. It goes on so easy and smooth.
Rating: - used to use clinique
I used to use Clinique also. I looked everywhere for other liners and tried many. This is the only one I have found that goes on dark with one application. I used to have to apply Clinique 2 or 3 times before I got the color I wanted. This also stays on a lot longer than the Clinique, which would smudge off. I will buy this again even if the other comes back. (If you like a lighter shade Clinique would work for you. Go to Lost But Not Forgotten they can get it for you.)
Rating: 
- Reallyreally pale
Because I have brown eyes, I bought the brown cake eyeliner.Big mistake.Not only is the 'brown' a really, really pale brown - barely noticeable after application, but it smudges off after barely 1/2 hour.Yuck.So is Clinique really back?I'm on my way to the mall to check.If it's there, I'm tossing this eyeliner in the trash and going back to the excellent Clinique.
Rating: - Arrrgghhhh
It runs, it smudges, it's not good without an mixing liquid which puts it right up there with the gels and liquid eyeliners.Besides ladies, Clinique IS BACK!
Rating: 
- eyeliner
Very nice product. Must have the correct brush for maximum effects however. It can be very tricky to use without a good brush.
- best eyelinerThis is the best eyeliner I have ever used. It goes on so easy and smooth.
- used to use cliniqueI used to use Clinique also. I looked everywhere for other liners and tried many. This is the only one I have found that goes on dark with one application. I used to have to apply Clinique 2 or 3 times before I got the color I wanted. This also stays on a lot longer than the Clinique, which would smudge off. I will buy this again even if the other comes back. (If you like a lighter shade Clinique would work for you. Go to Lost But Not Forgotten they can get it for you.)
- Reallyreally paleBecause I have brown eyes, I bought the brown cake eyeliner.Big mistake.Not only is the 'brown' a really, really pale brown - barely noticeable after application, but it smudges off after barely 1/2 hour.Yuck.So is Clinique really back?I'm on my way to the mall to check.If it's there, I'm tossing this eyeliner in the trash and going back to the excellent Clinique.
- ArrrgghhhhIt runs, it smudges, it's not good without an mixing liquid which puts it right up there with the gels and liquid eyeliners.Besides ladies, Clinique IS BACK!
- eyelinerVery nice product. Must have the correct brush for maximum effects however. It can be very tricky to use without a good brush.